If christians know anything about god from the cross, it is that the weakness of god is stronger than men 1 cor. The passibility of god volume 25 issue 2 charles taliaferro. Mozley poses at the end of his influential 1926 book, the impassibility of god. His possession of genuine character ensures his genuine feeling. God, emotion and impassibility volume one of two anastasia philippa scrutton phd 2008. I intend to do just that in the course of defending the thesis that the god of christian theism is passible in an important respect. The cross does not make god a helpless victim of evil, but is the secret of his power and his triumph over evil.
Divine immutability is denied by process theology which holds that god is involved in his creation and that he suffers along with us. God is conceived as a being than which none greater can be thought, and even the nonbeliever can grasp that idea. But for most of christian history theologians believed god could not suffer. The crimes of auschwitz are profound moral wrongs and may be recognized as obscene without supposing that god sorrows over the horrors. It argues that questions about the nature and value of emotions are at the heart of the im passibility debate. It is better to hold ones silence on so deep a mystery. The moral perfection of that character ensures his feeling appropriately. Request pdf divine passibility in light of two pictures of intercession the new testaments two pictures of divine intercession, that of the risen christ interceding at the right hand of god. Sometimes the impassibility of god is expressed philosophically in such a way as to describe god as being utterly incapable of feeling. This article surveys the philosophical literature on divine impassibility over the last 25 years, outlining major arguments for and against the idea that god has emotions. The predication of various emotional changes of state within god are not literal statements of his passibility, but illustrate and verify the literal truth that god, being transcendent, far from being fickle as men are, is unalterably, within all variable circumstances, allloving, allgood, and allholy.
Gods justice was absolute in condemning adams disobedience genesis 2. This chapter offers answers to the six questions that j. The predication of various emotional changes of state within god are not literal statements of his passibility, but illustrate and verify the literal truth that god, being transcendent, far from being fickle as men are, is unalterably, within all variable circumstances, all. It has often been seen as a consequence of divine aseity, the idea that god is absolutely independent of any other being, i. Each testamental section ends with a brief conclusion. Mcconville writes that verses 1718 represent again the pain of the lord through the mouth, and the experience, of jeremiah. Rather it is about becoming obedient, holy, wise and enduring saints of god. God says and identifies himself as i am, and the fullness, sufficiency, and blessedness of his life come from himself. The passibility of godthis quote on the passibility of god was taken from matthew henrys commentary on amos 9. The passibility of god religious studies cambridge core. Abstract the current theological climate presents two extremes in speaking of the emotional life of god.
In his post doug defends the traditional view of god, the view that the god of the bible is a god without body, parts, or passions. In the words of the westminster confession of faith, god is without body, parts, or passions, immutable. If there were several gods, there would be no unity of plan or power in the entire universe. Torrance on the passible impassibility of god stephen. Doug is quoting the thirtynine articles of the church of england. If you have access to a journal via a society or association membership, please browse to your society journal, select an article to view, and follow the instructions in this box.
Impassibility from latin in, not, passibilis, able to suffer, experience emotion describes the theological doctrine that god does not experience pain or pleasure from the actions of another being. It argues that questions about the nature and value of emotions are at the heart of the impassibility debate. Available formats pdf please select a format to send. Conversely, when the doctrine of divine passibility is taken to an extreme, the result is open theism, which views god as not knowing the future and being as surprised as we are by each turn of events. Of him, through him, and to himall ministry begins of jesus. Marcel sarot, god, passibility and corporeality kampen, the netherlands. In the midst of such suffering, god must himself suffer in solidarity with those who suffer. Divine impassibility a position paper concerning the doctrine of divine impassibility. Divine passibility in light of two pictures of intercession. The suffering of christ on the cross in the theology of. Gods impassibility and feelings third millennium ministries. Classic christian orthodoxy teaches that god is impassible that is, not subject to suffering, pain, or involuntary passions.
Classic theism teaches that god is impassible not subject to suffering, pain, or the ebb and flow of involuntary passions. Turner pdf files with commentary in new zealand icelandic meditations on the passion. Our perception of god as being the trinity is due to our perception from our timespace dimension. Ligon dun can ill, university of edinburgh determining the precise position of the westminster confession of. These concern whether gods nature is to be understood in terms of gods being absolute, immutable, and impassible, or as subject who engages in free actions. Still others are loathe to acknowledge gods passibility for varying reasons. Arguing for the doctrine of gods impassibility is the fact of gods immutability his unchanging nature. This spectrum multiview volume brings together four theologians who make a case for their own viewranging from a traditional affirmation of divine impassibility the idea that god does not suffer to the position that god is necessarily and intimately affected by creationand then each contributor responds to the others views. The doctrine of the passibility of god has to do with the theology of the suffering of god.
Gods actions unfold in the world as eternally willed, but which of the divine acts are realized depends upon which free acts creatures perform. God, so it must come from men, and their ideas about god, with of course the the god of this world hath blinded the minds of them which believe not, lest the light of the glorious gospel of christ, who is the image of god, should shine unto them. Access to society journal content varies across our titles. Presented by the theology committee of the association of reformed baptist churches of america formally approved by the general assembly on april 15, 2015 pdf. Presented by the theology committee of the association of reformed baptist churches of america formally approved by the general assembly on april 15, 2015. When we partake of jesus as the lamb of god, we are cleansed both from sin and the sin nature inherited from. For many theologians, the debate between divine impassibility and divine passibility will seem deeply puzzling. For the wages of sin is death gods justice, but the gift of god is eternal life through jesus christ. Gods impassibility and feelings reformed answers to. Jan 02, 2020 conversely, when the doctrine of divine passibility is taken to an extreme, the result is open theism, which views god as not knowing the future and being as surprised as we are by each turn of events. Sarot, god, passibility and corporeality kampen, the netherlands. The heresy in this theology is that the process god changes as he interacts with creation i.
In defining passibility, lee declares that god has a drive for reunion with humanity and this drive makes him participate in the world as an act of love the empathy of god creates the passibility of god. For the fathers the attribute of divine impassibility functioned in a restricted sense as an apophatic qualifier of all divine emotions and as an indicator of gods full and undiminished divinity. Torrance begins following cyril of alexandria in saying that god suffered impassibly in the death of christ, therefore calling the impassible passibility of god a paradox. This article surveys the philosophical literature on divine im passibility over the last 25 years, outlining major arguments for and against the idea that god has emotions. Whoever wants to be saved should think thus about the trinity. However, it was god who told jeremiah to tell judah that he, yahweh, was crying for their plight. It was god s intention that adam would choose the tree of life and become capable of achieving god s plan. God suffers for us a systematic inquiry into a concept of. Atonement, passibility, and cruciformity chester delagneau. Click download or read online button to get the impassibility of god book now. The impassibility of god download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl. Arguing for the doctrine of gods impassibility is the fact of. The last adam made the correct choice by being obedient to the will of the father. The passibility of god 219 horror of auschwitz is not contingent upon whether god is grieved by it.
We can argue that it is jeremiah, and not god, who is crying. Nor is the will of god even about success in ministry because that also can pander to our pride. In fact, divine passibility is at the heart of two ancient heresies. The emphasis tended to be laid sometimes on one side of the paradox, and sometimes on the other, but cyril was always concern not to detract either from the integrity of. God suffers for us a systematic inquiry into a concept. In this paper i argue that belief in gods passibility does not necessitate us to give up the idea that the cross of christ is constitutive of our. According t odcc,o impassibility rejects external passibility that god can be acted upon from without, interna l passibility that god can change within, and sensational passi bility that god can have feelings of pleasure or pain caused by another.
Passibility is a concept that moltmann uses to explain the suffering that god experiences. While the impassibility debate has traditionally been construed in terms. He can be affected by the actions of his creatures. The fathers at the same time admitted qualified divine passibility of the son of god within the framework of the incarnation. The order of these chapters reflects our hermeneutical method. In a desire to protect the immutability of god and to free him from all passions that would be dependent upon the actions of the creature and to insure the constant and abiding state of pure and total felicity. The impassibility of god download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. Passibilism, which affirms the fullness of gods emotional life, and. Divine impassibility association of reformed baptist. Thus god exists in the understanding, even if not in reality. Doug chaplin recently wrote a post in which he responded to my post on the passibility of god. Jurgen moltmanns theology of the passibility of god is examined as an example of a modern attempt to construct a theology with the suffering of god at its center. Indeed, a mark of a mature person is judging auschwitz evil for its crimes without.
The experience of immense suffering over the past century, especially the holocaust. God, passibility and corporeality kampen, the netherlands. The fathers at the same time admitted qualified divine passibility of the. Trinity and divine passibility in martin luthers theologia crucis dennis ngien, tyndale seminary, toronto introduction luther was certainly aware of the dictum of the athanasian creed. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. Gavrilyuk shows that the docetic, arian and nestorian alternatives represent different attempts at dissolving the paradox of the incarnation. Mar 10, 2011 doug chaplin recently wrote a post in which he responded to my post on the passibility of god. There is but one only, living, and true god, who is infinite in being and perfection, a most pure spirit, invisible, without body, parts, or passions. Oct 16, 2015 the order of these chapters reflects our hermeneutical method. This thesis is an attempt to understand cyril of alexandrias largely ignored and seemingly oxymoronic notion of christs impassible suffering visavis the idea of divine passibility reflected earlier by origen of alexandria and later by jurgen. Those who predicate any change whatsoever of god, whether with respect to his essence, knowledge, or will, diminish all his attributes.
816 1453 920 1402 288 1068 969 927 1349 793 1085 1300 361 348 1368 518 129 1252 730 387 474 408 1485 1081 575 370 1083 427 1294 191 370 269 1279 427 195 487 256 1268